Friday, September 28, 2012

Cookie Dough Dip Reviews

I went to a family party a few weeks ago and my husband's aunt served some Monster Cookie Dough Dip. It was really good and I decided to explore cookie dough dips myself. I wanted to do some side by side comparisons of different varieties. The perfect opportunity came up with my son's birthday party. He decided to invite a few buddies over for an all day video game & food fest. Instead of cake he wanted cookie dough. My kids always want to eat cookie dough but I won't let them because of the raw egg! I came up with 4 different flavors and served them with regular & chocolate animal crackers and vanilla wafers for dipping.
For Chocolate Chip I tried this recipe which uses cream cheese. It was good, but didn't taste like cookie dough. More like a creamy pie filling with chocolate chips and M&Ms. My taste testers liked this but not as cookie dough. 2 days later and we still have a little of this in the fridge. I will not make a cookie dough dip recipe with cream cheese again.
I bookmarked a recipe for Double Fudge Cookie Dough Dip recipe and when I went back to bookmark it I could not find it. Luckily I had written the recipe down. Instead of chocolate chips I added Reece's Pieces. This one was VERY yummy and actually tasted like cookie dough. The consistency was right too. It was my FAVORITE and I'll eat it right off the spoon! I will definitely serve this again!! No more of this left!!!
Double Fudge Cookie Dough Dip

1/2 cup butter, melted
1/2 cup brown sugar
1 cup sugar
1 cup flour
1/4 cup cocoa powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 Tablespoon vanilla
milk or heavy cream
chocolate chips or candy

Combine the butter & sugars, mix the flour, cocoa, & salt in another bowl
and then mix in with the wet mixture. Add vanilla. Add milk or cream a very
small amount at a time until it's the consistency that you want. I guess that I used 
about 1/4 cup of heavy cream. Add your chocolate chips or candies. Refrigerate.

I also did this Sugar Cookie Dough recipe. I divided the batter in half and put sprinkles in half for sugar cookies and cinnamon in the other half for snickerdoodles. This recipe was the least favorite. The snickerdoodle idea was a dud! I had to throw it out after the party. This is more of a cream dip, like the one you use for fruit, rather than cookie dough. The rest of the dough (without sprinkles or cinnamon) is still in my fridge. Sweets never last around here!
I am going to check out a few more recipes or maybe even mess with the Chocolate Fudge recipe and see how it turns out. Memes I link to listed here.

Diana is a crafty creative Midwestern work from home mama of 3. She enjoys playing with PhotoShop Elements, sewing & crafting, creating fun for family & friends, camping, and reading. She is the owner & operator of Custom Blog Designs.

You can follow Diana via Pinterest, Twitter, Facebook, & Instagram


  1. We are so glad you linked up to our Strut Your Stuff Saturday with your delicious Cookie Dough Dips!! YUMMY! We hope you'll be back and thanks for sharing!! -The Sisters

  2. Yum! These looked good, thanks for testing them out so we know which ones are the best! So excited to try them out!
    Keep up the amazing work :)
    Thanks for sharing at Artsy Corner!

  3. Oh these look delicious! If you ever need a partner to help test out any future dips... Thanks so much for sharing at Mom On Timeout!

  4. Hi Diana,
    What a special treat, I want to try them all. Enjoy your weekend and thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday.
    Come Back Soon!
    Miz Helen

  5. Hi Diana,
    What a fun idea. I love the honesty about what works and what doesn't. I will need to try the chocolate one. My family would love that. Thanks so much for sharing at Wednesday's Adorned From Above Link Party.
    Debi @ Adorned From Above


Thanks so much for leaving a comment. I moderate all my comments. I like to reply to comments and will do so via email, directly below the comment, or even on the commenter's blog itself. If you are a no-reply blogger you might not hear from me. If you have word verification on, it's likely that I will NOT leave a comment for you. Please turn it off!

Comments with links in them will not be published!